Home » Posts tagged "children’s books" (Page 31)

Is Any Book A Good Book?

Well, the answer to that question is obvious, I think. Of course not. Some books are just not very good. As a review site, of course we discriminate between what makes a story worth reading, and what doesn’t. Otherwise, what good would we be as a resource for readers and librarians? We all have limited time and money for books.

But MonsterLibrarian.com is just that. A resource. People see what we have to say and make their own choices based on that, and probably also recommendations from friends, colleagues, Goodreads, and other review sites, advertisements on the Internet, catalogs and flyers in your mailbox (if you’re a librarian) and reviews in magazines and publications of various kinds. You choose where you’ll go for recommendations, and who you’ll trust to direct you to the “next good book” as we like to say here. I hope you choose to come here and take advantage of our hard work.

To go a little further, is any book that gets people reading a “good book”? I think Dylan, the Monster Librarian, would say yes. And this is a philosophy that I see a lot. Are the Twilight books good books? They got a lot of people reading. That’s a good thing… but are they good books? I think the writing is pretty bad, so I’m going to say no, I don’t think they are. Would I buy them for my YA collection, if I were buying for one? With such high demand, you’ve gotta give them what they want. You don’t take books out of the hands of people who are desperate to read them, especially if this is the first time they’ve ever really wanted to read a book. And I do know people for whom Twilight was the first book they read from cover to cover. But not the last.

I don’t especially like the school of thought that says “well, it’s okay to let them get the bug with R.L. Stine, because at least they’re reading, and that will transfer into a love of great literature in the future”. Maybe, but that’s condescending to those kids. Stine doesn’t even pretend that his books have classic literary value. Like a lot of series books, his books use fairly simple language, predictable structure, and cliffhangers at the endings of chapters to keep kids going. Not everything kids read is great literature, even in the classroom. If you have seen some of the little phonics readers kids use you know that is not even expected. “I put my hat in the van. I put the map in the van. Dad gets in the van”. Simple language, predictable structure (no cliffhangers, though, sadly). We can share the cool books that aren’t Goosebumps or Twilight without seeing them as just a stepping stone. They’re where the reader IS. And maybe the reader will be there for a long time. There are enough Goosebumps books and knockoffs to last the kid who wants them or needs them for a very long time.

But there are also a lot of other books– fiction, nonfiction, and graphic novels for kids that are funny and suspenseful and unbelievable. And someday kids will be done with Goosebumps, just like kids from 30 years ago eventually outgrew the series adventures of Elizabeth and Jessica Wakefield and kids from 60 years ago eventually outgrew Nancy Drew to go on to other kinds of books. Maybe their interests will take them in the direction of new, similar series and genre fiction(which is often, despite its disreputable status in literary circles, extremely good) and maybe their reading will be shaped by other interests and experiences. Some of those books might be food for thought– but maybe not the ones we might expect. And some may be pure escapism (also maybe not the ones we might expect).

Not every book is a good book. But sometimes it’s enough to tell a good story, one that fits readers at their particular time and place. But those books don’t exist in isolation, even if the reader has a narrow view. Put those stories in the midst of many, and let serendipity take us on its meandering course on the shelves and through the stacks, whether that’s in the classroom, in the library, or at home.

Help A Reader Out: Short Giant?

Andrea wrote:

I am looking for a book that I lost a few years ago that I used to love to read. It was a book of complete of short stories from around the world and it was for children. I know that 2 of the words that are in the title are Giant and Short (giant was in red and short was in yellow). The cover had a combination of witches, vampires, zombies, tombstones, and children on the cover. It was dark blue and black to help give off the “scary book” feel. I hope you can help me find this book.

ETA: Andrea found the book herself. It is called Giant, Short, and Shivery, and is one of many collections assembled by Robert D. San Souci. Published in 1998, it is now out of print, but maybe you can find a copy at your library. If you don’t see that particular collection you might try More Short and Shivery and Even More Short and Shivery, available both in print and ebook format. San Souci has several other scary story collections, and also has written many picture books, mainly based on folktales and fairy tales, that would be appropriate for even children who don’t care for shivers down the spine.

Thanks, Andrea!

The Not-Halloween Book List for Kids

It drives me bananas that my kids’ school doesn’t even recognize the existence of Halloween. Their preschools encouraged costumes, had Halloween parties, and even invited parents to a Halloween parade. The school I taught at, a public elementary school in a rural area (where you might think there would be objections) encouraged costumes, had Halloween parties, and held a costume parade. The day of Halloween, my cadet teacher showed up in a bloodstained cafeteria worker’s uniform with a dismembered arm in her pocket and a beatific smile on her face (which was the scariest part, really). But at the school my children now attend, there’s no such holiday. It’s sad, really. But I understand– public schools are under siege from all directions for the way holidays are celebrated (or not celebrated, for that matter). And there are lots of other schools in the same situation, as well as parents who are looking for slightly spooky but not too scary picture books for their little ones. So here are a few to try out.  Not all of them have been reviewed on the site, but you can click on the titles of the ones we’ve reviewed to find out a little more about them. Enjoy!

 

The Not-Halloween Book List for Kids from MonsterLibrarian.com

 

Pumpkin Circle: The Story of a Garden by George Levenson and Shmuel Thayer

This is a great book that traces the growth of a pumpkin’s life cycle. It’s got beautiful photographs and is a perfect complement to the trip to the pumpkin field that kids will probably make either with their class or their parents.

 

Bat Jamboree by Kathi Appelt and Melissa Sweet

Bats definitely have their place in the Halloween season, but it is possible to go batty without ever mentioning the holiday. Bat Jamboree is a very silly concept book that preschoolers and kindergarteners will love. There’s a second book as well, called Bats Around The Clock.

 

Red Leaf, Yellow Leaf by Lois Ehlert

Lois Ehlert’s wonderful illustrations and simple language are a perfect way to introduce the colors of the season.

 

Spooky Hayride by Brian James (Level 1 Scholastic Reader)

This is a wonderful easy reader that will satisfy any kid who has ever been tricked by their big brother. Or wanted to trick him.

 

Little Goblins Ten by Pamela Jane and Jane Manning

This is a fun counting book based on the rhyme “Over in the Meadow”.

 

Where the Wild Things Are by Maurice Sendak

Okay, this one can be scary for some kids, but others find it exhilirating, especially when they get to “roll their terrible eyes, and gnash their terrible teeth”.

 

A Beasty Story by Bill Martin, Jr. and Steven Kellogg

Perhaps you are familiar with the story that begins “There was a dark, dark, wood…” Imagine that made into a cartoony concept book that reinforces kids’ knowledge of colors, and you have one of my favorite kindergarten reads. You can’t go wrong with an author/illustration combination like Bill Martin, Jr. and Steven Kellogg!

 

Skeleton Hiccups by Margery Cuyler and S.D. Schindler

Skeleton has the hiccups, and desperately wants a cure. It doesn’t get much sillier than watching a skeleton attempt to drink a glass of water in an attempt to get rid of them.

 

The Gobble-uns’ll Git You Ef You Don’t Watch Out! James Whitcomb Riley’s “Little Orphant Annie” by James Whitcomb Riley and Joel Schick

Sadly, this book has been out of print for years and years, and it’s doubtful that it ever will be reprinted. But you just can’t have October here without mentioning the great Hoosier poet James Whitcomb Riley. Even if you can’t get your hands on this wonderfully illustrated book, with its menacing cartoon gobble-uns, find yourself a copy of “Little Orphant Annie” to share with your kids. It’s a fantastic read-aloud. I loved Riley when I was a kid– what an amazing imagination the man had!