In The Woods(Dublin Murder Squad #1) by Tana French

Viking, 2007

ISBN-13 ‏ : ‎ 978-0670038602

Available: Used hardcover, Kindle edition, paperback, mass market paperback, audiobook.

( Bookshop.org | Amazon.com )

In one of the sessions at StokerCon this year panelists brought up the Suburban Gothic. Does it exist? The suburbs probably don’t seem like a source of dark family secrets and horrific events to you,  but I live in the suburbs, and there’s a lot more hidden beneath the surface than most people might expect.

What better place to start exploring Suburban Gothic than with In the Woods (Dublin Murder Squad #1) by Tana French? Taking place in 2004 Ireland, this is a messed up story from the beginning. Twenty years ago, three twelve-year-old kids disappeared into the wooded area behind their subdivision, and only one of them was found, with his clothes covered in blood, unable to remember anything. The survivor, Adam Ryan, moved across the country, started going by another name, and eventually worked his way up though police bureaucracy to the elite Dublin Murder Squad. Now a new murder has been committed in the same place… is it possible it is the same person responsible for his friends’ disappearance? Rob’s partner Cassie is doubtful that he can be objective, but she keeps his secret as the two of them investigate the murder of a twelve-year-old girl found on a sacrificial altar at an archaeological site near the woods.

Rob, the narrator, is an unreliable narrator who disintegrates in front of the reader’s eyes as his memories start to unravel and the personality he’s constructed for himself since his friends’ disappearance begins to peel away. It’s unclear even how much of what he’s telling us is actually happening and how much his mind is playing tricks on him as he and Cassie track down leads on their current case, thinking that perhaps it will also lead to the solution of Rob’s friends’ disappearance. In the midst of it all the workers at the dig are up against a deadline as developers plan to dig up the site to start construction on a motorway, and (speaking from experience here) there’s nothing like corrupt developers with money on the line and government officials in their pocket to liven up surburbanites against new construction.

French does a great job with build ups, but I felt her follow through on plot points and building relationships was sometimes a let down, or confusing. Character development is confusing, possibly because we are seeing everything through Rob’s eyes and his perceptions are unreliable. Rob himself is not an especially likable character–and from the beginning pages we know he can’t be trusted– but I loved the friendship between Rob and Cassie and was not happy with how French handled it at the end. French’s language can be evocative and lyrical: the woods of the title appear a magical, haunted place, even as close to the rather prosaic subdivision Rob, and the victim he is investigating, grew up in.

Compelling and disturbing until the last few pages (there is one major, essential piece of the story that is never explained, leaving it with a bothersome hole at the end) Tana French has successfully evoked Suburban Gothic, the darkness that lies under the pleasant-looking surface of suburbia.